Constructive Dismissal in Canada: A Complete Guide for Employees & Employers

Constructive dismissal is a critical concept in Canadian employment law that protects workers when employers impose unilateral, fundamental changes to their job terms—effectively forcing resignation. This guide explains:

✅ What constitutes constructive dismissal
✅ Key factors that trigger it
✅ Legal recourse for employees
✅ How employers can avoid claims

What Is Constructive Dismissal?

Constructive dismissal occurs when an employer makes significant, unsanctioned changes to an employment contract, leaving the employee with no reasonable choice but to quit. Legally, this is treated as a termination without cause, entitling the employee to severance or damages.

Example Scenario:

An employee hired as a senior manager is suddenly demoted to an entry-level role with a 40% pay cut. If they resign due to these changes, it may qualify as constructive dismissal.

4 Key Factors That Lead to Constructive Dismissal

Canadian courts recognize constructive dismissal when:

1. Major Changes to Job Duties

• Demotion without cause

• Removal of core responsibilities

• Assignment of unreasonable tasks

2. Reduction in Pay or Benefits

• Salary cuts without agreement

• Loss of bonuses, pensions, or health benefits

3. Hostile Work Environment

• Harassment, bullying, or discrimination

• Failure to address toxic workplace complaints

4. Forced Relocation

• Mandatory move to a distant location

• No prior discussion or compensation for added hardship

Legal Recourse for Employees

Step 1: Resign Promptly

• Delaying resignation may imply acceptance of new terms.

• Document all changes (emails, memos, pay stubs).

Step 2: Consult an Employment Lawyer

• A lawyer assesses if the case meets legal thresholds.

• They help calculate owed compensation (severance, lost wages).

Step 3: File a Wrongful Dismissal Claim

• Options:

  • Sue for damages in court

  • File a complaint with the Ministry of Labour (in some provinces)

• Possible compensation:

  • Pay in lieu of notice

  • Benefits, bonuses, and mental distress damages

How Courts Evaluate Claims

Judges consider:

Key Precedent: Farber v. Royal Trust Co.

• The Supreme Court of Canada ruled that unilateral contract changes = dismissal.

• Employers must consult employees before altering key terms.

How Employers Can Avoid Constructive Dismissal Claims

1. Obtain Written Consent for Changes

• Use contract amendments signed by the employee.

2. Provide Advance Notice

• Give reasonable time to adjust or negotiate.

3. Offer Alternatives

• Example: Instead of a pay cut, propose temporary reduced hours.

4. Document Business Reasons

• Prove changes were bona fide (e.g., restructuring to avoid layoffs).

Conclusion: Protecting Rights & Avoiding Pitfalls

For employees, constructive dismissal is a safeguard against unfair treatment. If faced with drastic changes:
➡ Act quickly
➡ Seek legal advice
➡ Pursue fair compensation

For employers, proactive steps prevent costly lawsuits:
➡ Communicate transparently
➡ Get employee buy-in
➡ Document business needs

📌 Need Help? Consult an employment lawyer to navigate these complex issues.

Engage With Us

💬 Have you experienced constructive dismissal? Share your story below!
🔗 Tag someone who needs to know their rights!